12 baby names with a similar sound and feel to Nattie.
You searched for names like
"gift of God"
"farmer, earth-worker (from George)"
"fortune, riches"
"good; well; true"
"from the narrow strait"
"young girl, lass"
"Praise, offering"
"modern variant of Majella"
"fortunate warrior"
"verdant, green"
"free woman (via Charlotte)"